How internet changes the handling of social incidents in China

Today I want to begin with a pretty good summary of how internet change the way social incidents are treated in China.  It was from a speech intended to give at the 2008 Chinese blogger conference by Roland Soong, one of the most influential bloggers in the Greater China Area who translates daily news and updates from the Chinese blogsphere into English.  You can find his blog “EastSouthWestNorth” here.

There are two observations we can get from the pictures he gives: First, after the arrival of the internet, social grievances have many more channels to be heard and its more likely for them to be addressed.  Second, it seems like afte the internet boom in China, western media plays a much less influential role in shaping governments’ response to social incidents.  One reason is perhaps that they cannot be as updated as the p2p communication on net, and another is perhaps, after China’s rise, CCP honestly does not care that much about what foreign media says anymore.  It’s the opinion of the people that they take serious notice of.   And it’s arguably true that, foreign media in general lost their credibility to shape the opionion of Chinese people due to their hostilities – some perceived, some manisfested – towards China’s rise since the 2008 Olympic Games.

In Soong’s view, that’s how social incidents are treated in the pre-internet era:

1. A bad thing happens somewhere in China (such as police brutality, government malfeasance, a forced eviction, a coal mine disaster, etc).

2. The local government suppresses all information.

3. All media reports are censored.  [If it wasn’t reported, it didn’t happen as far as people are concerned.]

4. The victims begin a petitioning process up the hierarchy in order to seek justice.  The road is long and hard (see The Long Road To Petition) with dim prospects.

Yet things start to change around 2003 when Soong himself started blogging.

1. A bad thing happens somewhere in China (such as police brutality, government malfeasance, a forced eviction, a coal mine disaster, etc).

2. The local government suppresses all information.

3. All media reports are censored.  [But if it wasn’t reported in traditional media, there are other alternatives now on the Internet.]

4. The victims begin a petitioning process up the hierarchy in order to seek justice.  The road is long and hard, and nothing ever comes out of it.

5. The Internet forums/blogs rushed to report on the case.  But within approximately 48 hours, all traces of information are erased by order of the authorities.  [Thus, one of the excitements of my blogging activity was to find and translate that information before this window closes.]

6. Western media catch wind of the incident, and follow through.  This creates an international scandal.

7. Senior Chinese officials take notice, and corrective actions are taken.

And that’s how things are done now:

1. A bad thing happens somewhere in China (such as police brutality, government malfeasance, a forced eviction, a coal mine disaster, etc).

2. The local government suppresses all information.

3. All media reports are censored.

4. The victims begin a petitioning process up the hierarchy in order to seek justice.  The road is long and hard and nothing ever results.

5. The Internet forums/blogs rushed to report on the case.

6a. Within 48 hours, all traces of negative (i.e. against the authorities) information are erased by order of the authorities, or else by self-censorship at the portals/forums/blog service providers.

6b. Positive (i.e. on behalf of the authorities) information appear from Internet commentators who are paid by the authorities for their efforts.

6. Western media catch wind of the incident, and follow through with an international incident.

7.  But there are just too many portals/forums/blogs that important information will eventually seep through.

8. Senior Chinese officials take notice, and corrective actions are taken.

Advertisements

Leave a comment

Filed under Facts of China's internet that might surprise you, Uncategorized

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s